DeWITT COUNTY COURTHOUSE
Cuero, Texas

What does a turkey drive, a thirty-year feud, a lady in a clock, and a headless horseman have in common? The answer is DeWitt County.

The present county of DeWitt, named for colonizer Green DeWitt, was created from parts of Gonzales, Victoria, and Goliad counties in 1846. Since that time, there have been three courthouses in three different cities, including its present county seat, Cuero. Somebody or somebodies didn't care for the second courthouse because on Sunday night, April 8, 1894, it was torched. The Hallettsville Herald said it had been an eyesore to that beautiful city for many years*.

The replacement building was definitely not an eyesore. But getting there was a challenge.

Acclaimed Austin architect A. O. Watson both designed and built the courthouse. He had quite a time funding it, however. Finally in December 1896, the unpaid workers walked away, leaving the courthouse without a roof. Citizens complained. I guess it would be hard to hold court with rain beating down on your heads.

Watson went broke on his "labor of love." Winter was looming, when in steps Eugene Heiner, who saw its completion. DeWitt county got not one, but two Golden Age architects constructing their courthouse.

The 1897 Courthouse & Lady in the Courthouse Clock

This 1897 Romanesque revival style structure is built of brown sandstone and pink granite quarried from near Marble Falls. Initially, the tower and the corner roofs were topped with fluted finials. Soon, at night on the lighted face of the clock on the north appeared the shadow of a full-skirted woman moving back and forth. No one knew who she was or why she was pacing. Some figured she was the ghost of a lady who had died waiting for her boyfriend to return. Her spirit then flew up to the courthouse clock. Maybe that way her boyfriend could find her more easily.

Thirty years later, one of the four lower finials fell. Officials feared someone might be killed if others fell, so all the ornaments were removed. Legend has it that the lady in the clock had something to do with it, for right after that, she was gone forever. One of the original finials is kept in storage in the courthouse. I got a look at it, and it's taller than three watermelons stacked up on top of each other and fairly hefty. I wouldn't want that thing falling on me either.

Another oddity is that one of the balusters on the second floor balcony above the Gonzales Street entrance is upside down. The workers noticed it, but they thought that no one else would.

The Sutton-Taylor Feud
El Muerto, the headless horseman

Now, the county has had its share of trouble makers. The most infamous ones are those who were involved in the Sutton-Taylor Feud. No one knows why this thirty-year fight started, but eventually over one thousand people were involved, including gunslinger John Wesley Hardin. Records of this court case are on display in the foyer of the courthouse.

The patriarch of the Taylor clan, Creed Taylor, was a former Texas Ranger, a Texas Revolution fighter, and cattleman. At one point, he and his Texas Ranger friend, Bigfoot Wallace, tracked down and killed a Mexican bandit who had been stealing horses and cattle for many years, including Creed's horses. Wallace made an example of this bandit, resulting in El Muerto, the headless horseman. Legend has it that this horseman, with its head dangling, can still be seen riding across DeWitt County during the darkest nights. You'll know when you see them because lightning flashes from the ghostly wild mustang's hooves and flames burst from the eyes of the severed head. Sounds like a wild ride.