by Johnny Stucco
The Crystal City Statue That Might’ve Been
Max Sandfield's proposed statue of Popeye.
Sketch courtesy Norman Sandfield
the many whimsical statues
around the state of Texas - Popeye, of
Crystal City is one of the most photographed. Or it would be if Crystal
City was a little closer to a major highway.
Not only has Popeye been the unpaid spokesman for spinach for 75 years,
his statue has also become the unofficial ambassador for Crystal
Standing in Zavala County, far from his beloved coast hasn’t been
easy for the sailor without a surname, but his facsimile takes this
inland imprisonment with characteristic stoicism. In his slightly
belligerent pose, with his famous anorexic biceps and pumped-up forearms,
he seems to be silently saying, “I yam what I yam!” (What else would
Looking as shiny as a spray-painted pinata, this fiberglass effigy
shares a secret with museum statuary in Rome, Paris and London. The
secret is: (they are reproductions). To protect Popeye from vandals,
the “real” statue stands safely within the walls of the Crystal City
Hall. This duplicate is placed as an offering to whatever rival high
school teams might want to defame or insult the Crystal City team
by defacing the now-famous landmark.
Once the most recognizable sailor in the world, Popeye’s popularity
has dipped in recent years. Despite a severe (and unique) speech impediment;
he managed to get the message across to millions of children world-wide,
that (given a chance) iron-rich spinach could cure everything from
pellagra to bullies. And, if you ate enough of the stuff, you wouldn't
even need a can-opener.
The statue is not actually a monument to Popeye, but to his creator,
E. C. Segar, of Chester Illinois. Segar, who made the astounding sum
of $400,000 a year in the 1930s, died [mysteriously] at the age of
38. Mr. Segar’s signature on the statue’s base today might be appearing
on a very different statue if the vote of a design committee had gone
statue of Popeye in Crystal City
TE photo, November 2001
contest was held back in 1937 to award the contract. A man named Max
Sandfield saw the announcement and entered the fray. Sandfield, a
native of Lithuania, had been raised in San Antonio and was residing
there when he read of the competetion. He was already a practicing
architect, having earned his degree from MIT in 1925. He practiced
in both San Antonio and New York before moving to Dallas in 1945.
Sandfield’s entry shows a statue far different from the one standing
today in Crystal
City. In his sketch, Mr. Sanfield has Popeye sitting on a can
of spinach about the size of a 55-gallon drum with a more-to-scale
second can held against his chest, ready to be opened in case of an
emergency - or upon the arrival of Bluto. The pipe is there of course,
along with the familiar squint and tattoo, but the one thing that’s
different - really different - is the proposed material.
Max Sandfield suggested that Popeye be carved from native Texas limestone.
Today the suggestion would’ve won him the contest hands-down, but
back in 1937 limestone might have been considered too dignified for
a mere cartoon character - despite whatever contributions to nutrition-awareness.
Medina, Texas has since erected an oversized limestone apple - and
courthouses around the state are carved with a variety of flora, fauna,
and limestone cowboys. It appears Mr. Sandfield’s proposal was ahead
of its time.
1937 announcement in Design Magazine (Volume XVIII Number 3) shows
Mr. Sandfield’s drawing with the text reading:
Spinach Growers Honor Popeye
A statue of “Popeye” will be erected in the Winter Garden Section
in Crystal City,
Texas in honor of E.C. Segar, creator of the “Popeye” comic strip
if an idea proposed by O. P. Schnabel, San Antonio manager of the
Jefferson Standard Life Insurance Company, is carried out.
A drawing of the proposed statue has been made by Max M. Sandfield,
San Antonio Architect. The statue, to be carved of Texas limestone,
will be in the form of a large can of spinach as a base with Popeye
sitting on the can eating out of another can. The erection of this
statue in the heart of the world’s greatest spinach-growing country
will be a fitting tribute to the man who has made both young and old
If Mr. Sandfield was disappointed that his proposed design was not
used, it didn't discourage him. In collaboration with Howard Meyer,
Max Sandfield’s design of Dallas’
Temple Emmanu-el was hailed at its 1957 dedication as “one of the
handsomest synagogues in the United States.” The quote comes from
the Encyclopedia Britannica.. The temple was also awarded a 1957 Merit
Award from the American Institute of Architects and Mr. Sandfield
received a 25-Year Award from the Dallas branch of the AIA, an organization
he once served as president.
Sandfield was also a noted home designer and sculptor and several
pieces of his work accent the courtyards at the temple. The Columbian
Country Club in Carrolton, Texas was another noted Sandfield design.
Festival Office in Crystal City.
TE photo Nov. 2002
is known of the design competetion or the judging. Any information
would be appreciated, including any details of (alleged) Spinach-eating
contests held in the 30s. The Crystal City chamber of commerce was
unavailable for comment - but a recording assured us our call would
Other Popeyes - Other States
One bronze statue of Popeye stands in E. C. Segar's hometown of
Chester, Illinois. Vandals have pulled it down on at least one occassion
Two others stand in Arkansas about 70 miles apart. In Alma, Arkansas,
off I-40, the paper-mache statue was stolen so often that it had
to be covered in fiberglass and chained in place. The other Arkansas
statue is near Springdale about 60 miles North. Considering this
recent hostility toward cartoon statues, Crystal City is wise to
keep a spare.
Our thanks to Mr. Norman Sandfield of Chicago for making us aware
of his father's design and for providing the content used in this
© John Troesser
"They shoe horses,
don't they?" September 11, 2004 Column